Why I teach you to understand your body, not just follow a plan.
In my last post, What Good Coaching Looks Like in 2026, I talked about how the fitness industry is moving toward more individualized, data-informed coaching with a greater emphasis on long-term health.
It's encouraging to see, especially because it's how I've structured my coaching business from the beginning.
But I want to talk about what that actually looks like when we're working together.
Because I think there's an important distinction between giving someone a plan that works and teaching them enough about their own physiology to understand why it works.
And for me, that second part is where a lot of the value of coaching lives.
Most of the women who come to me aren't starting from zero. They've tried different ways of eating. They've followed workout programs, tracked calories, cut carbohydrates, or spent years trying to figure out why something that used to work doesn't seem to work anymore.
They have plenty of information.
What they're often missing is the context to know:
- which information applies to them,
- what their body is actually responding to,
- and how to adjust when their circumstances change.
That's where we start.
Why I use tracking, and why I don't want you dependent on it.
When a new nutrition client starts working with me, the first week isn't about changing anything.
I ask her to eat normally and track what she's eating.
Not an idealized version of her diet. Not a week of suddenly making all the choices she thinks her nutrition coach wants to see.
Just a normal week.
I want to understand her eating patterns, meal timing, food preferences, and how much energy she's currently taking in. I also want to know about her activity, training, sleep, stress, digestion, and the goals we're working toward.
Because before I start adjusting someone's nutrition, I need to understand what we're adjusting.
That first week can show us very different things:
- Sometimes that first week shows us that protein intake is lower than expected.
- Sometimes someone is eating enough over the course of the day but not distributing that energy very well around training.
- Other times, someone has been trying to eat as little as possible while simultaneously asking their body to recover from running and lifting.
Those are very different starting points.
After that baseline, I build personalized macro and habit targets that account for the individual's needs and goals.
Yes, I use numbers. I think they're useful.
Research on dietary self-monitoring supports its effectiveness in weight-management interventions. But I don't want tracking to become another set of rules someone feels incapable of functioning without.
I want it to teach you something.
- What does an adequate serving of protein actually look like?
- How much carbohydrate does your training require?
- Are you eating enough earlier in the day to support your energy and appetite later?
- What happens to your hunger when training volume increases?
These are things we can learn through tracking, but they're also things you can eventually recognize without needing to enter every ingredient into an app.
For some clients, continued tracking makes sense because they enjoy the structure or have a specific performance or body composition goal. For others, we gradually move toward more flexible methods, using meal structure, portion awareness, and the patterns they've learned.
There's no requirement that everyone has to arrive at the same relationship with tracking.
I just want the numbers to serve a purpose beyond giving you more numbers to manage.
I care about what your body is telling us, not just what the numbers say.
This is probably where my coaching differs most from simply downloading a macro calculator and following its recommendations.
Every week, my clients check in with me about far more than their food intake or weight.
We're looking at energy, sleep, hunger, digestion, stress, menstrual cycle changes when relevant, training, soreness, and recovery.
And I'm looking for relationships between those things.
- If your weight hasn't changed for a week, that doesn't automatically mean we need to reduce calories.
- If you're suddenly hungrier, I want to know whether your training volume has increased, whether you've been sleeping poorly, whether you're approaching your period, or whether your meals have become less consistent.
- If your easy runs are feeling unusually difficult, I'm interested in more than your pace. I want to understand your fueling, training load, recovery, and what else has been happening that week.
One data point rarely gives us the whole answer.
And that's an important part of what I want my clients to learn.
- A higher number on the scale doesn't automatically mean you've gained body fat.
- Increased hunger doesn't mean you've lost control.
- A difficult run doesn't necessarily mean you've lost fitness.
There are physiological reasons our bodies respond differently from one day or week to the next.
Understanding those responses gives us a much better foundation for making decisions.
Sometimes we adjust the plan. Sometimes we gather more information. And sometimes we leave things alone because normal fluctuations don't require intervention.
Good coaching requires knowing the difference.
Understanding nutrition gives you more flexibility, not less.
I don't believe we need to replace one set of food rules with another.
I have clients who arrive believing:
- they shouldn't eat carbohydrates after a certain time,
- that eating before an early run will interfere with fat loss,
- or that certain foods simply don't belong in a healthy diet.
I understand where those beliefs come from. Nutrition information is everywhere, and so much of it is presented without any context.
But when we understand how energy balance works, how carbohydrates support exercise, and how protein supports muscle repair and adaptation, we can start making decisions based on physiology rather than fear.
Consider someone training for a half marathon who also wants to improve her body composition.
She may have spent years trying to keep her carbohydrate intake as low as possible because she associates carbs with weight gain.
But now she's asking her body to run several days a week, complete harder workouts, and recover well enough to do it again.
Her carbohydrate needs are going to be influenced by that training.
So rather than simply telling her to eat more carbs, I explain why we need them, how to distribute them around training, and what we're looking for as we adjust.
The same applies to protein, dietary fats, fiber, hydration, and total energy intake.
I want my clients to understand what each of these contributes, not just hit a target because I told them to.
Research on flexible versus rigid dietary restraint also gives us a reason to take this approach seriously. Flexible restraint has been associated with better long-term weight-management outcomes, while rigid restraint has been associated with greater preoccupation with food.
There's a meaningful difference between having structure and feeling controlled by it.
And I think a good nutrition program should help you develop the first without reinforcing the second.
Different goals require different seasons.
One of the things I spend a lot of time helping clients understand is that we cannot prioritize every goal equally, all the time.
You might want to run a faster marathon, lose body fat, build muscle, and improve your overall health.
Those are all reasonable goals.
But the strategy that best supports one of them may not be the strategy that best supports another.
This is why I use intentional nutrition phases and look at the bigger picture of someone's training year.
- Building: There are times when we focus on building. That might mean increasing training volume, supporting muscle growth, or improving nutritional consistency after a period of inadequate fueling.
- Deficit: There are times when a calorie deficit makes sense for someone pursuing a body composition goal.
- Maintenance: And there are times when maintenance is exactly where we need to be.
I don't view maintenance as the absence of progress.
It's an opportunity to practice eating at a level that supports your current needs, continue training, and learn how your body responds without constantly trying to change your weight.
For my runners, this becomes especially important.
When we're building toward a marathon, the priority is supporting the work. We need enough energy to train, recover, and adapt. A sustained energy deficit during demanding training can compromise those processes, particularly when energy availability becomes too low.
So rather than trying to force fat loss into the middle of a demanding race build, I prefer to organize body composition goals around periods when training demands are lower.
That doesn't mean you can only work on one aspect of your health at a time.
It means we understand which goal is driving our decisions and make sure the rest of the plan supports it.
And when that priority changes, the strategy changes too.
I'm thinking about the body you'll have in 20 years, too.
I work with a lot of women in their late 30s, 40s, and beyond, and I think this is an especially important conversation to have.
There is so much messaging around this stage of life that makes women feel as though their bodies are suddenly working against them.
- Their metabolism is broken.
- Their hormones are ruining their progress.
- They need to eat less, exercise more, and somehow be even more disciplined than they were before.
But the physiology is much more nuanced than that.
A large study of daily energy expenditure found that after accounting for differences in body size and composition, average energy expenditure remains relatively stable from approximately ages 20 to 60.
That doesn't mean our energy needs never change.
Muscle mass, movement, training volume, sleep, health, and changes in body composition all influence our individual needs. Hormonal transitions can also affect symptoms, recovery, and the way we experience training.
But it does mean we should be careful about attributing every change in our 40s to a metabolism that's supposedly stopped working.
This is part of why strength training and adequate nutrition are so important to me.
Muscle supports much more than appearance. It contributes to physical function, glucose regulation, metabolic health, and our ability to remain active as we age.
Resistance training also provides an important stimulus for maintaining strength and supporting bone health.
And none of that happens independently of nutrition.
- Adequate protein helps support muscle repair and adaptation.
- Carbohydrates support training performance.
- Sufficient total energy is necessary to recover and maintain normal physiological function.
This is why I don't look at running, lifting, and nutrition as unrelated parts of someone's health.
Even when a client is only working with me on one of those areas, I want to understand what's happening in the others.
And when we combine them, the goal is to make sure they're working together rather than competing for the same limited recovery resources.
We're not just training for the next race or working toward the next body composition goal.
We're building the physical capacity to keep doing the things we love as we get older.
What I actually want you to take away from coaching.
When we work together, you get structure.
You get personalized targets, programming, regular check-ins, feedback, and adjustments based on how you're responding.
You also get an explanation of why we're doing what we're doing.
- If I increase your carbohydrates, I want you to understand why.
- If we're moving from a deficit into maintenance, I want you to understand why.
- If your running plan changes because your recovery hasn't been keeping up with your training, I want you to understand that decision too.
And over time, I want you to start recognizing some of these things yourself.
- Maybe you realize that your afternoon energy is better when you eat a more substantial breakfast.
- Maybe you start fueling your long runs consistently because you've experienced the difference it makes.
- Maybe you take a vacation and don't track a single meal, but you still understand how to build a balanced plate and return to your normal routine without feeling like you've lost all your progress.
That's learning.
And that learning matters just as much to me as the numbers we're working toward.
This is also why I have an eight-week minimum for my nutrition coaching. We're not just trying to produce a short-term change. We're gathering information, implementing strategies, evaluating how your body responds, and giving you time to practice.
Eight weeks isn't a finish line for developing habits or understanding your physiology. It's a starting commitment to a process that requires more than a few days of doing everything perfectly.
I want you to reach your goals. Whether that's improving your race performance, changing your body composition, building muscle, or simply feeling better and having more energy.
Those outcomes matter.
But I also want you to leave coaching with something that isn't tied to a specific number, training cycle, or nutrition phase.
I want you to understand your body well enough to know what it needs, recognize when something isn't working, and feel confident making adjustments as your life and goals change.
Because a plan can tell you what to do today.
Understanding gives you the ability to make those decisions for yourself years from now.
And that's the part of coaching I care about most.
Explore my 1:1 coaching options β
Research referenced
- Burke et al. (2011): Self-monitoring in weight loss
- Westenhoefer et al. (2013): Flexible and rigid restrained eating behaviour
- Pontzer et al. (2021): Daily energy expenditure through the human life course
- Westcott (2012): Resistance training is medicine
- Mountjoy et al. (2023): IOC consensus on relative energy deficiency in sport

