Fueling Like the Pros

Sometimes the answer isn't more training. Sometimes it's more fuel. After Jess McClain's runner-up finish at the New York City Marathon, her coach David Roche argued that American runners train too hard and don't fuel enough. Here's why that conversation matters well beyond professional running.

I've been thinking a lot about a conversation that came out of the New York City Marathon earlier this month.

On November 1, Jess McClain finished second in 2:24:42, becoming the first American woman to reach the NYC Marathon podium since 2018.

This came after running 2:20:49 at Boston in April, the fastest time ever recorded by an American woman on that course.

Pretty incredible year for a 34-year-old who finished fourth at the 2024 Olympic Marathon Trials, just missing the team.

But what caught my attention wasn't necessarily the performances themselves. It was a conversation her coach, David Roche, had afterward about the way we're training and fueling endurance athletes.

In a November 11 interview covered by LetsRun, Roche made the argument that American distance runners tend to train too hard and don't fuel enough.

And I think that's a conversation worth having well beyond professional running.

Because while the training demands of an elite marathoner and a recreational runner look very different, the physiology we're working with is largely the same.

We're getting better at understanding what fueling actually does.

For a long time, endurance sports operated under some pretty persistent assumptions about body weight, carbohydrate intake, and what it meant to be disciplined.

Eat less. Train more. Get lighter. Get faster.

And while our understanding of sports nutrition has evolved considerably, some of those ideas are still hanging around, especially among recreational runners.

What's interesting about Roche's approach is how deliberately he prioritizes carbohydrate availability alongside training intensity and recovery.

He also practices what he teaches.

In 2024, Roche broke the Leadville 100 course record while consuming approximately 120–140 grams of carbohydrate per hour. In 2025, he returned and broke his own record.

Those are enormous amounts of carbohydrate, and certainly not what every runner needs.

But they illustrate a larger shift in endurance sports.

Instead of asking how little an athlete can get away with eating, we're asking how much fuel they can actually use to support performance.

That's a very different approach.

And it's one I think recreational runners can learn a lot from.

More training only works if you can adapt to it.

This is the piece I wish more runners understood.

Training creates a stimulus. Your body responds to that stimulus through a series of adaptations that happen during recovery.

And recovery isn't just a rest day on your calendar.

It requires energy.

Carbohydrates help maintain blood glucose during exercise and replenish muscle glycogen afterward. Protein supports muscle repair and remodeling. Adequate total energy intake supports the broader physiological processes involved in adapting to training.

When we consistently fall short on energy, we're potentially limiting our ability to benefit from the work we're doing.

And that's where I think a lot of recreational runners get stuck.

They assume that if progress has slowed, they need more miles, harder workouts, or greater consistency.

Sometimes those things are appropriate.

But sometimes the missing piece is simply having enough energy available to support the training they're already doing.

You can be incredibly consistent with your training and still be under-supporting it.

And this is where the research gets interesting.

Low energy availability occurs when the energy remaining after exercise isn't sufficient to adequately support the body's other physiological functions.

When that becomes problematic, it can contribute to a condition called Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport, or REDs.

The International Olympic Committee's 2023 consensus statement describes a wide range of potential health and performance consequences, including disruptions to reproductive function, impaired bone health, metabolic changes, reduced immunity, and psychological symptoms.

And importantly, this isn't something that exclusively affects elite athletes or runners in smaller bodies.

It can happen across body sizes, performance levels, and training backgrounds.

Now, I want to be careful here because I think the conversation around underfueling can sometimes swing too far in the other direction.

Not every plateau is caused by inadequate nutrition.

Not every tired runner has REDs.

And having an occasional low-calorie day doesn't automatically mean you're compromising your health.

What matters is the bigger picture: your total energy intake, training demands, recovery, and how your body is responding over time.

But if you're consistently increasing the work you're asking your body to do without increasing the energy available to support it, that's worth examining.

Carbohydrates aren't just race-day nutrition.

One of the biggest gaps I see in recreational runners isn't necessarily how they fuel a marathon.

It's how they fuel the training that gets them there.

We put a lot of emphasis on race-day gels, hydration plans, and carb loading.

All important.

But the everyday stuff matters too.

If you're running early in the morning, heading straight into work or family responsibilities, and not eating a substantial meal until hours later, you may be making it harder to meet your overall needs.

If you're doing harder sessions with minimal carbohydrate availability, you may be compromising the quality of those sessions.

And if you're consistently treating your running calories as something you need to compensate for later, you may be creating an energy gap that accumulates over time.

This doesn't mean every 30-minute easy run requires a gel.

It doesn't mean you need to force yourself to eat immediately before every workout.

And it definitely doesn't mean every runner needs 120 grams of carbohydrates an hour.

It means matching your fueling strategy to the work you're asking your body to do.

For many runners, that looks like:

  • Having some easily digestible carbohydrate before demanding morning sessions instead of routinely starting them underfueled.

  • Practicing carbohydrate intake during longer runs. Around 30–60 grams per hour is a useful starting range for many efforts lasting 1–2.5 hours, with higher intakes often appropriate for longer events.

  • Eating enough carbohydrate throughout the day to replenish glycogen stores and support subsequent training.

  • Including protein and carbohydrate in recovery meals, particularly when training again within a short period.

  • Adjusting total food intake as training volume and intensity change.

None of this is especially exciting.

But that's kind of the point.

We spend so much time looking for the workout, supplement, or training method that's going to unlock the next level of performance.

Meanwhile, some of the most meaningful improvements may come from doing the basic things consistently enough that our bodies can actually respond to the training.

The other part of this conversation is learning when to back off.

Roche's comments weren't exclusively about nutrition.

He also discussed the tendency for runners to accumulate too much intensity.

And I think these two things belong in the same conversation.

Because you can fuel appropriately and still be training harder than you can recover from.

Likewise, you can follow a beautifully periodized training plan and still struggle to adapt if you're consistently underfueling it.

The goal isn't to maximize how much work you can squeeze into a week.

It's to find the amount of training you can consistently recover from, adapt to, and build upon.

That means easy runs need to be easy enough to serve their purpose.

Hard workouts need to have a reason for being there.

And food needs to support all of it.

More isn't automatically better, whether we're talking about mileage, intensity, or even carbohydrate intake.

The right amount is the amount that supports the work and the adaptation you're trying to create.

So what can we learn from Jess McClain?

I don't think the takeaway from McClain's performances is that everyone needs to start eating enormous amounts of carbohydrate or copy the training methods of an elite marathoner.

And I certainly wouldn't attribute her success to one variable. She's an exceptionally talented athlete with years of training behind her.

But I do think her success, and the broader conversation Roche is contributing to, offers an important reminder.

There is a difference between working hard and creating the conditions that allow hard work to pay off.

For the recreational runner balancing training with jobs, families, stress, and everything else life requires, that distinction might be even more important.

You don't have to train like a professional athlete.

But you can absolutely learn from how professionals are approaching the relationship between training, fueling, and recovery.

And maybe the next time your running feels stagnant, instead of immediately asking what more you could be doing, ask whether you're giving your body what it needs to benefit from what you're already doing.

Sometimes the answer isn't more training.

Sometimes it's more fuel.

And sometimes it's a little less of one and a little more of the other.

About Coach Kirsten

I'm Kirsten, a UESCA run and endurance sports nutrition coach and NASM strength and nutrition coach in Monterey. I started structured running at 39 after years as a collegiate volleyball player, and I've run marathons, half marathons, injuries, and comebacks while raising three boys. I'm your science-loving running bestie, here to see you win.

Next
Next

Running in the Dark: A Safety Checklist for Women Runners